Israeli Society / Society

Why many religious Jews only have frum friends

In Israel it is very common that frum Jews mostly have frum friends. Ba’ale’i Teshuva (newly religious Jews) may be an exception because they usually have secular parents, siblings and other family members. During and after their Teshuva (repentance) process, many Ba’ale’i Teshuva also prefer to associate with religious Jews rather than with the secular world.
Frum from birth Jews already come from a religious background. Meaning, they went to religious schools, Yeshivot, seminaries, etc. Hardly anyone can escape the secular world because one has to go the bank, the post office, various government institutions, etc. However, it is a fact that religious Jews have religious friends and are not necessarily looking for secular friends.
The same is happening on “the other side”. Whereas secular Jews may have a couple of national religious (Mizrachi) friends, it rarely ever happens that Haredim have secular friends. But, as I said, it could happen in Ba’ale’i Teshuva circles. For instance, when a Jew turned haredi and you see him walking around with his secular parents or siblings. But it is very unlikely that frum from birth Haredim have secular friends.
What could be the reason for this behaviour?
Although secular and religious Israelis work together, they don’t really befriend each other in a way that they invite each other for Shabbat. They just don’t become really close friends.
I have found myself in the same situation many times. Working with secular and religious Jews. At first, it drove me nuts when the secular walked in on a Sunday morning and immediately started to talk about what they did on Shabbat. Baking a cake or traveling. I have to say that I got used to this after a while and it stopped bothering me.
While working in Tel Aviv many years ago, I had a pretty bad experience. A female co-worker constantly accused me of being a religious fundamentalist. The reason: Because I live in Jerusalem.
I hadn’t told her anything about Judaism and our conversations were related to our job. However, she was a radical leftist and in her eyes, everybody coming from Jerusalem is either a settler, Kahane or Mea Shearim.
I have to say that such a stupid behaviour is not very common and I have only come across it once. On the other hand, this kind of behaviour wouldn’t necessarily happen within the religious community. According to my experience, it is mostly the secular community bashing religious Jews and not vice versa. Some secular Jews feel the urge to bash religious Jews.
But what is the reason for religious Jews preferring religious friends?
People usually make friends with others who share the same interests and even opinions. I have nothing against people with other opinions but I also wouldn’t like to get into discussions or fights all the time. Why putting oneself in a situation where you constantly have to justify yourself?
When religious people go out they go to a kosher cafe or restaurant. As soon as a secular Jew recommends a restaurant, you have to check whether the place is kosher. And if not, your secular friend may be offended when you don’t show up. The same issue comes up when your secular friends is inviting you to his home, as his kitchen is probably not kosher.
Secular and religious Jews have definitely a lot of topics to talk about but when it comes to politics, Judaism or even certain morality or modesty standards, people can easily end up in a fight.
Another reason may be the language. Religious people share the same kind of language. No, I am not talking about Hebrew but the religious “language” such as Torah insights, Halacha or Mussar. Secular Jews wouldn’t even understand the vocabulary and, at the same time, frum Jews wouldn’t understand the secular vocabulary either. Example: Slang.
There are many reasons and the more I mention, the more I realize that this issue probably exists in every society. Certain groups of people like to associate with each other and not too much with outsiders. We all make friends with people we can mostly relate to. This is the way we are.

6 thoughts on “Why many religious Jews only have frum friends

  1. the kind of befriending you are writing about is accompanied by “influence” on yourself and your family haredi people avoid on purpose

  2. B”H

    Having secular or even national religious friends could destroy one’s haredi reputation. Your Yeshiva career or a good Shidduch would be in danger and your family could lose it’s reputation.

    This is the way society works.

    In Toldot Aharon, no one is allowed to have friends from the outside. This is even stipulated in the group’s Takanot.

    • Baruch Hashem these takanot are not that black and white but come in different shades of grey as well. We came in contact with a Toldos Aharon family in 1990, we were searching and learning about Jiddishkeit and a giur. This family introduced us to Admor Harav Awrohom Yitzchok zal, we were invited to all kind of simches of TA and later TAY as well. The family is our family and we still visit them each year as I do go to both Rebbes and their Shabbos tish. After our four 12 years ago I had a mitswa dance with the Rebbe of TAY during Simcha Tora. And mind you we are not chassidim and live in a small kehilla and I work as a detective in a police force, a shomer Shabbos one. Greetings

  3. I wrote about influence of behaviour and other spiriual influence.I absolutely don’t agree with your interpretation.

  4. B”H

    Ups, my interpretation was wrong. Sorry!

    There is a danger of spiritual influence. Especially when it comes to the younger generation.

  5. B”H

    @ Avraham Yitzchak

    The Toldot Avraham Yitzchak Rebbe is well-known for his open mind. Sometimes I see him as Chabad of Mea Shearim. Rebbe Yaakov Shmuel Kahn welcomes everyone but I cannot say whether all of his Chassidim really agree to this policy. Many of them look more than strict and reality shows that, if the Rebbe accepts an outsider into his group, the outsider will never become part of the inner circle. But this is not only happening in Toldot Avraham Yitzchak but in all other groups including Chabad.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s